Taestful Face-Off: Tangled vs. Frozen

May the best movie win!*

*Nine categories have been carefully picked to decisively crown the deserving winner

FrozenTangledMoviePoster

Why are these movies facing off?
Once the character design for Anna came out, people instantly complained about Frozen’s alleged similarity to Tangled. Much of that controversy has led people to compare the two movies, sparking debates as to which movie is the superior Disney computer-animated princess musical. I’ve linked one such debate down below. Keep reading to see me debate with myself?


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BkqUtoUxNDc

Yeah, look, they have eyebrows, eyes, a nose, and a mouth in relatively the same location.

Yeah, look, they have eyebrows, eyes, a nose, and a mouth in relatively the same location.

Is it because... maybe... I don't know... that they're both HUMAN?!?

Is it because… maybe… I don’t know… that they’re both HUMAN?!?

Category One: Animation/Backgrounds/Effects
Both Tangled and Frozen are strong in this category, but the winner is obvious for me. Tangled looks better than Frozen, even being 3 years older. I actually think the troubled production of Tangled helped the film out in this regard, since legendary animator Glen Keane was director for then-called Rapunzel until health issues got in the way. Glen Keane wanted to infuse the unique artistic style of traditional animation into computer animation, using non-photorealistic rendering to try to make every frame look like a painting. The texture of Tangled is the best we’ve seen from any computer animated film so far, reminding me of the visible brush strokes often associated with paintings. This isn’t anything against Frozen, which did a remarkable job with every snow/ice effect, but the backgrounds felt lazy, the textures were only really noticeable on stuff like clothing, and the animation amazed in moments, not consistently.

Winner: Tangled (1-0)

The painting behind/below Anna, found in Frozen, was concept art for Tangled (based on a real painting called The Swing).

The painting behind/below Anna, found in Frozen, was concept art for Tangled (based on a real painting called The Swing).

TangledTheSwing

Category Two: Soundtrack/Songs
Uhh… some of the deleted Frozen songs are better than Tangled’s (Mother Knows Best). To be fair, Frozen Heart was a crappy way to open the movie, and Tangled has a real gem in I See the Light.

Winner: Frozen (1-1)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=66MQPWZ-n0g

AnnaSinging

Category Three: The Princess
This is a little difficult since Frozen has double the dosage of princesses, but even when excluding the complicated Elsa, Anna is more interesting and relatable than Rapunzel. Both are energetic and optimistic, making Anna and Rapunzel extremely likeable protagonists. And while both add humor into the story, Rapunzel knowing nothing about the outside world and Anna being a hopelessly romantic, stuttering clutz, I think Rapunzel’s persistent dream of seeing “the lights” (as poetic as it is) will be far less understandable than Anna’s dream of falling in love, hanging out with people, and building a snowman with her sister. Plus, Rapunzel doesn’t seem to struggle with bad hair days like the rest of us.

Winner: Frozen (2-1)

AnnaSleeping

Category Four: The Love Interest
Once again, Frozen kind of has two, but I’m going to boil this down to Kristoff vs. Flynn Rider. While neither are particular stand-outs (I mean, the Disney princes tend to be rather boring) I think Rider is at least better developed. Sure, screen time helps, but Rider has a legitimate character arc. All he cares about is his reputation and money at the beginning, but he never comes off as a total jerk. Just someone who is hiding behind a facade. Now that’s intriguing. And the fact Rapunzel accepts him for who he is underneath, Eugene, makes the love story all the more believable and meaningful. I like how Frozen paired up the two underdogs/outcasts of the story, but Kristoff is just not too compelling. He didn’t even realize the little girl who he saw healed was Anna.

Winner: Tangled (2-2)

Eugene

Category Five: Comic Relief Characters
Both Tangled and Frozen primarily utilizes a pair of side characters for most of their humor, Pascal + Maximus and Sven + Olaf. In this new, so called “revival” era of Disney’s, they have definitely benefited from working with silent side characters, and while I still love Olaf, I just think Pascal and Maximus fits into the story/movie better. I complained early on about Olaf’s cartoonish design clashing with the rest of the character designs shown in the Frozen trailers/teasers, and I still stand by that statement even if he did warm my heart with his child-like naivety and knack for great comedic timing. Sven is definitely the weak link in this otherwise pretty hilarious group of four.

Winner: Tangled (3-2)

Pascal

Category Six: The Villain
Gotta pick the lesser of the evils here (more evil?) since Mother Gothel and Hans can’t compete with the Queen from Snow White, Maleficent, Cruella de Vil, Ursula, Scar, and Frollo. I’m going to have to pick Mother Gothel here. She’s manipulative, she’s conniving, she’s just despicable. Hans’ reveal kind of comes out of nowhere, but perhaps I’m not giving him enough credit for almost stealing both Anna’s heart and her kingdom.

Winner: Tangled (4-2)

MotherGothel

Category Seven: Story/Substance
For as good as Tangled was, I’ve always wondered what was the idea inspiring the movie. I mean, sure, you have influential Disney veterans trying to translate the Disney princess brand into computer animation, but what type of a message did they want little kids to learn from Tangled? I think Tangled is about things, but the central theme of dreams running through the story just didn’t have closure by the end. Frozen, on the other hand, saves their best surprises for last, where they subversively tell children to think about their sister instead of prince charming. Now that’s a message I can get behind.

Winner: Frozen (3-4)

AnnaUnfreezes

Category Eight: Storytelling/Execution
I’ve heard people complain about Tangled trying to be too modern and what not, but I think it worked. Tangled maintained the fairytale feeling of Disney’s earlier works while embracing its modernity through obviously animation medium, but also through song, humor, characterizations, pacing, and dialogue. For as catchy as the entire Frozen soundtrack is, I actually couldn’t enjoy the music quite as much on my first viewing. Love is an Open Door and Fixer Upper felt too hip for a setting where there are still legitimate kings, queens, castles, balls, and wooden ships. Add robot dancing and a running gag about being married in one day, and I think I’ve provided enough reasons why Frozen is the one that was trying to be too modern/satirical.

Winner: Tangled (5-3)

ISeeTheLightConceptArt

Category Nine: Innovation/Novelty
As unique and likeable as many Disney protagonists are, Disney’s stories typically revolve around making their dream come true, leaving little room for dynamic character growth. There are a few exceptions in which their plight also involves overcoming personal insecurities frequently essential for character growth, like Beast, Mulan, and Elsa. In the end, I think that’s why people wanted to see more of Elsa. She’s conflicted, and while her heart is in the right place, her mind-set was simply self-destructive. People connected with Elsa, and when she finally liberated herself by singing Let it Go, her anthem was bound to become viral. Coupled with Elsa’s younger sister who dealt with problems of normality/rejection, and you have one of Disney’s most character-driven story. Tangled was more about atmosphere and introducing classic Disney to a new generation of children. Needless to say, Frozen deviated further from the usual Disney path.

Winner: Frozen (4-5)

Elsa

Final Verdict: Tangled (5-4)

Winner

In a close battle, Tangled edges out Frozen, winning in important categories like animation and storytelling, while getting destroyed in other categories like soundtrack. Did the right movie win? Which movies do you wanna see face-off next? Let me know in the comments below and come revisit this site to catch the next Taestful Face-Off.

Pixar2015FaceOffPosters

Advertisements

17 thoughts on “Taestful Face-Off: Tangled vs. Frozen

  1. Great series! I too had to think like this for a long time to decide which of the two movies I thought were better/I liked better and I too chose ‘Tangled’ over ‘Frozen’.

    You should do a ‘The Little Mermaid’ and ‘Beauty and the Beast’ face-off.

    • Thanks Mark! I’m happy to hear that you agree with my selection for winner. I was actually considering doing BatB vs. TLM! I’ll definitely consider it more strongly now that you’ve suggested it!

  2. “Tangled” beats out “Frozen” for me too. Great point about the animation in “Tangled!” You’re right in how it does have a more artistic style and feeling than “Frozen,” namely with the backgrounds. But when it comes to the princesses, I really love Rapunzel. I actually think her dream about seeing the lights is relatable too. Not in that many of us what to see floating lights, but in how we all have that one dream where we need to take risks and let go of our fears. I think that trumps Anna’s basic “finding the one” dream by a mile.

    • Thanks for commenting Brittany! I’m glad you agree with my discussion of the animation.

      Now that you bring it up, Rapunzel does have to leave her tower/disobey her mom in order to pursue her dreams. I still relate with Anna more, but I probably should have given Rapunzel more credit for being, well, awesome. Hope you get to Rapunzel soon in your saving the disney princess project. Would love to read more about why you love Rapunzel!

      • It’s funny cause I relate to both Rapunzel and Anna in some ways so I go back forth lol! Yeah I’m hoping to pick up speed in the series now that I have some more time. πŸ™‚

  3. Hmm…I probably would have left out comparing the love interests. I don’t think that Kristoff is exactly a match for Flynn Rider/Eugene. Kristoff’s the tritagonist of Frozen, and unlike Eugene, he kind of had to take a back seat for two female leads (like where “true love = sisters, not romance). But pretty good face-off!

      • I agree with you. I feel like these films are compared to a little too much and the way some people kind of fight over with one is better is overbearing to me.

  4. Hey Kevin. It has been a bit since we have spoken.

    Well, neither film are in my Top 15 WDAS films, but I did enjoy them enough. I agree that Tangled is better than Frozen in a lot of aspects, and Frozen suffers from the same issues as The Princess and the Frog (I did go there XD).

    I agree with almost every single point you made, and I like this new series.

    • Hey AnimatedKid! It’s nice to hear from you again. I’ve enjoyed reading your opinion on the Disney renaissance so far! I agree with a lot that you have to say. Wondering what you think about Mulan and Tarzan, some of Disney’s more mature work I would say, ending the lively Broadway style usually characterizing the Disney renaissance.

      I’m glad you like this series! Hopefully there will be more posts to come out of this segment.

      • Well, I know about Hunchback, Mulan, Tarzan, Aladdin, Beauty and the Beast, Princess and the Frog, Wreck-it Ralph, Lilo and Stitch, Lady and the Tramp, Peter Pan, Ichabod and Mr Toad, Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, Pinocchio, The Rescuers, and………….. Cinderella are my Top 15.

      • I like the list AnimatedKid. I haven’t seen Ichabod and Mr. Toad, but I’m surprised TLM didn’t make the list. Now that I think about it, a top 15 list would be pretty difficult to make. TLM, Bambi, Fantasia, Frozen, Tangled, Fox and the Hound, and The Emperor’s New Groove are movies I all like, but didn’t make it into your list, and I haven’t even seen all of the WDAS movies. Glad to see Lilo and Stitch sneak into your list πŸ™‚

  5. Very interesting article that I generally agree with. I kind of want to do my own version of this, haha. I really love Rapunzel — I think she lights up the screen in a special way. She’s one of my favorite Disney characters to watch. But my wife maintains that Anna is better developed and stronger, and I think I have to agree.

    To me, the big question is whether Frozen’s all-time great soundtrack is enough to overcome its weird plot and pacing faults (like Hans out-of-nowhere reversal) and its annoying-as-hell side character Olaf (you liked him?).

    And I think the answer is no, not quite — mostly because of “I See the Light,” which is as good as most of the Frozen songs. I also think that scene is more magical than any single scene in Frozen.

    BTW: Sven > Maximus > Pascal >>> Olaf

    • Hey Dan! I think I might have a slight crush on Anna (wrote an entire tribute for her), so I’m definitely biased here haha. As for Olaf, I thought I was going to hate him (trailers), but I don’t know, I was won-over right after his quick In Summer number. He had me laughing early and often.

      I See the Light harkens back to the Disney renaissance days of magic carpet rides and elegant ballroom dances. It jumped Tangled into my “Great Movies” list (A- or higher), and without that staple number, perhaps Frozen would have won this face-off.

  6. Pingback: Taestful Face-Off: The Little Mermaid vs. Beauty and the Beast | taestful reviews

Feel free to comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s