Animation Review Part Fourteen: Disney Loses Their Touch, Moana Is Sea-Sickening

Moana rehearses over and over again before meeting the great shape-shifting demigod Maui, “I am Moana.” “I am Moana.” “I am Moana.”

moanamovieposter

Spoilers ahead

The directors of The Little Mermaid (and Princess and the Frog) approach this project with a sense of liberty. They don’t feel tied to musical numbers or romance but half the time, it feels like they’ve forgotten the great opportunity on their hands to showcase a culture that honestly doesn’t get enough representation in media. I doubt anybody remembers the musical numbers by name, but We Know The Way is an authentic musical number because it fully embraces the Hawaiian language and instruments custom to their heritage. And whether you personally like the piece or not (I know I did) it has to be insulting when this type of music is rapidly replaced by pop, Broadway, and jazz as the screenplay progresses. Why? Why did they do this? Think about what this suggests about Hawaiian culture.

This doesn’t play into the narrative that Disney tends for caricature when it comes to depicting cultures outside of the Western world. This feeds into the fact that they just don’t care.

ronclementsjohnmuskermoana

Directors Ron Clements and John Musker

Moana’s Part of Your World/Almost There in the form of How Far I’ll Go comes far too early and unjustified. Whereas Ariel and Tiana faced real opposition from their society to which they wanted to escape, Moana speaks on this innate affinity for the water. Just because the water becomes anthropomorphic for her doesn’t justify a big musical number. I’m sorry, it just doesn’t.

Her father is a mild form of Triton, giving him just enough backstory to make him logical in his actions but not berserk enough to have Moana run away without external reason (or deal with the devil, for that matter). When her island’s food resources withers from strange anomalies, her dying grandmother spills Hawaiian folklore to initiate her long love affair with the sea and to answer her call for adventure.

grammatala

I imagine if Belle were more able, this would be the adventure she would take and it’s nice to see it come to fruition. Moana’s journey, although bogged down by unnecessary details and uninteresting pit-stops, is absolutely stunning and lush. The sea truly forms as its own character, adding life and dimension to the story. Why is Moana the chosen one, asks Maui.

In many ways, Moana reminds me of Mulan. She constantly feels inferior to the male role models she looks up to, whether that is her father or Maui. Maui has to be one of the most confusing characters ever written by the Disney company. His self-exuberant motives are consistent throughout, but you have to wonder what drives him into thinking higher of the people below him. He too gets a backstory which is lazily integrated into the story and never feels like it fully resolves.

mauimoana

Still, this is Moana’s story, and she shares this beautiful moment with her grandma’s spirit off shore. And although none of the visuals are memorable or iconic, it is the only song that seems to answer the question: “Who am I?”

I am a girl who loves my island. I’m the girl who loves the sea. It calls me…

The real heart-beat of the story lies in the relationship between Moana and her grandmother, and I simply wished other tangential relationships were stripped down so their interaction could take center stage. I imagine if Gramma Tala’s death was more impactful, they could have magnified the effect intended from this song and crafted a truly powerful musical number.

But alas, without strong musical numbers to back-up characters who are poorly written and a story with little potential, Moana’s self-identity search is all we have left to keep us in our seats. She is a girl who loves her island. She’s the girl who loves the sea. It calls her…

Moana.jpg

In my mind, Moana represents the Hawaiian people. Their loyalty to their island, people, and family–their love for water and their call for adventure. I imagine that even if Disney didn’t properly represent their culture to mainstream America, they will appreciate this general characterization which is thankfully more sophisticated than the broad stroking of Native Americans as tree-hugging environmentalists as found in Pocahontas.

In the same breath, Moana also represents Disney’s constant ridiculing of their own princess brand and Disney’s erratic song choices in recent years. I think this is the first time in which I frequently identified Moana as being similar to another Disney princess. Although there is a noticeable omission of a popular Disney princess trope–that being the presence of a love interest–there is also the distinct omission of catchy musical numbers, likeable characters, and a magical story. To see critics be blind to such atrocities time and time again in 2016 has made this year one of my worst movie-going experiences I can recall. Go in with low expectations and maybe then you can shake off a fraction of the disappointment I felt while watching Moana travel miles and miles for ultimately nothing.

Advertisements

17 thoughts on “Animation Review Part Fourteen: Disney Loses Their Touch, Moana Is Sea-Sickening

  1. Wow. Sorry you have such a miserable experience. I loved it! I thought Moana was a great character and the songs were very catchy. Different strokes I guess.

  2. Interesting….

    I have heard some good things about it, but from what I heard about the plot, there is always a bit of worry in me. I hope I won’t be disappointed by the film.

    Which film is the best of the year to you?

  3. So it is more or less what I expected. That’s too bad, especially considering a lot of effort and excitement seems to have gone into this movie. The trailers made me suspect it would turn out a very generic adventure story, and I failed to see anything that made the main character, or any other for that matter, stand out.

    It’s curious that you mention Disney’s recent tendency to deride their formula. I don’t think it is a good idea for stories to define themselves by contrast to other stories, when their whole identity is reduced to not being like that other thing. I got the idea that Moana was coming across as a generic action heroine in the trailers, and one of the things I like about Disney is that their characters are not, as a general rule, action heroines.

    • Yes, the trailers didn’t look so good in my eyes either. Sorry I never got the chance to comment on it prior to the movie.

      I couldn’t agree more. Everyone loves The Little Mermaid, Beauty and the Beast, Aladdin, etc. I don’t know why they don’t make movies like those anymore. Frozen gave me hope because of the music but this was a severe let-down in almost every major aspect, including Moana herself. Hope you like it more than I did when you get the chance to see it.

      • I feel the same about Disney movies these days. Something always feels missing, and I have a hard time putting my finger on it– so perplexing.

  4. I finally got around to watching Moana today, and I will say that while it does have heart, I do have some issues with it. Maui was weirdly handled, and while I do get Moana’s journey, it is easy to say it was not executed the best. It was odd to me that they never showed the islands reaction to her leaving for the sea, and I did get bored in the second act with just seeing the sea.

    I like how the story was simplified, and the first act was really strong. Learning about the culture, and her role as an upcoming heir is something that hasn’t really been explored since A Bugs Life. The soundtrack is nice, and the animation is lovely, but there was some missing opportunity.

    • I didn’t make the connection to A Bug’s Life but I see it now that you bring it up. Glad you liked the soundtrack–I also loved the animation–but I also can’t avoid seeing the flaws as you mentioned. Cheers.

Feel free to comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s